|
Steve de Shazer

11 November 2005
__________________________________________
Insoo Kim Berg

10 January, 2007
The solution focus community has lost the 2 people most
responsible for the development and growth of interest in solution focused brief
practice. I have been fortunate to have known and have trained with both Insoo
and Steve. I have also been fortunate to have seen both of them work with
clients and to know first hand how they have each respected the individual's
resources and wisdom. For obituaries of both, click on their
pictures.

|
NEW BOOK
I'm proud to announce that a book I co-authored
with Dr. Thorana Nelson has been published by Haworth Press. The
book is entitled Solution-Focused Brief Practice with Long Term
Clients in Mental Health Services: "I'm More Than my
Label" and is available through Taylor & Francis. To learn more, click
here |
The Difference
Between Problem Solving and Solution Building
In my years of doing
therapy, I have yet to meet someone who has come in to see me who
woke up in the morning, realized that they have spontaneously
developed a problem and therefore needed to see a therapist.
Most (if not all) of the people I've had the pleasure to work with,
have experienced a problem for quite some time; they've talked
about the problem with friends, family members, perhaps a clergy
member, maybe co-workers, etc and yet the problem has persisted and
in may cases, has even gotten worse. From a social
constructivist point of view, this makes perfect sense. Our
conversations and how we make meanings together with others
co-constructs what we experience as being real. Simply put,
the more we talk about the problem, the more the problem becomes
real. Consulting with a therapist is usually one of the last
things that people do in hopes of resolving what seems to be
intractable problems. Steve de Shazer said that the problem
with most people is that they don't extend the logic to it's (often
absurd) conclusion. Nothing brings that point home clearer
than the idea that many therapists practice from a problem-solving
orientation that requires greater clarification, description and,
theoretically, insight to the problem. According to this
orientation, it is the insight that leads to the eventual resolution
of the problem. A failure in resolution is a failure in
problem detail and therefore more information is required. One
can see the absurdity of this position; the client has already
thought about and talked about the problem long before seeing a
therapist. They then go to a problem-focused therapist to do
more talking about the problem and then wonder why things are not
getting better and maybe even getting worse. You probably
already have heard this saying: true insanity is doing the
same thing over and over and expecting a different result. In
their book, Change, Principles of Problem Formation and
Resolution, Paul Watzlawick, John Weakland, and Richard Fisch,
present a 9-dot puzzle. I'm reproducing it here. You
might want to play around with it for a while and see how you do.
°
° °
°
° °
°
° °
Here are 9 dots. The object is to draw 4
straight lines so that each one of the dots is intersected by at
least one line. The following rules apply:
-
You can intersect lines, you can't retrace
lines.
-
A line is defined by the shortest distance
between any 2 dots (this is a puzzle on a 2-dimensional plane)
-
The lines must be contiguous. That is,
wherever you choose to start the first line, you don't remove
the pencil from the paper until all 4 lines are drawn.
I've created a printable form with several 9-dot
puzzles. If you like you can download that and play around
with this for a while. Frustrated? Here is a solution.
Waltzlawick, et al, make the distinction between
first-order and second-order change. First-order change is a change
that doesn't make a difference. The client changes with whom
they talk about the problem, but it doesn't result in a difference
that makes a difference. The therapist using a traditional
problem-solving approach is engaging in first-order change. A
second-order change is a change that makes a difference to the
client and this often requires looking for resources in the client's
life that exist beyond the dots. Have a
question, or thought about the above or solution-focus in
general? Feel free to email me by submitting this feedback form. If appropriate, I'll include your questions (with
responses) and thoughts below. Thanks for taking the
time. Joel
Top
For further information contact Joel
at joelsim@frontiernet.net
|